PSA lists 6,451 stolen items and disables certs

PSA has published a list of 6,451 stolen graded collectibles and disabled their certification numbers. By October 24, 2026, compensation payments had begun. The list gives collectors item-level details to identify missing cards.

The missing items include sports cards, Pokémon cards and other card games. PSA has started contacting affected customers, with different compensation routes depending on the shipping label used for each order.

The update follows PSA’s earlier refund announcement after the October 13, 2026, theft from a FedEx truck near its Santa Ana facility.

Certification numbers and the missing list

PSA’s list includes certification numbers and, for cards that have them, serial numbers. The company shared the records with auction houses and marketplace sellers, which are watching for the missing items.

The disabled certification numbers cover every stolen graded item. PSA also supplied shipment manifests, video footage and records for individual items to support recovery efforts.

Pokémon accounts for 2,978 entries, and One Piece accounts for 898, according to TheGamer. Basketball has 880 entries, followed by baseball with 640 and football with 433.

The list extends beyond those larger groups. It includes 89 wrestling items, 58 Yu-Gi-Oh! cards and 56 Dragon Ball cards. Soccer accounts for 43 items, while tennis accounts for 40.

Other entries include 27 Lorcana cards, 23 hockey items and 16 Digimon cards. Magic: The Gathering accounts for 8 entries. The breakdown also includes 226 items under an other category and 14 unidentified sports items.

Refunds and compensation

PSA has refunded grading fees for affected orders. Those refunds remain separate from compensation for the stolen items and do not reduce it.

Customers do not need to wait for recovery efforts to finish before receiving compensation, according to Dexerto.

For orders sent with a PSA shipping label, PSA’s insurance applies. Customers can begin the compensation process, and the company has started issuing payments.

PSA will work directly with customers who supplied their own shipping labels. Customers who submitted through a dealer should contact that dealer about their order.

Compensation uses each item’s fair market value, capped at its declared maximum insured value, according to the New York Post. Customers who accept compensation can still reclaim their cards if the items are recovered later.

PSA has assigned a dedicated team to affected customers. Customers who need help can contact PSA support about their orders.

What to do

• Check your order’s certification numbers against the stolen-item list, including serial numbers where listed.
• Confirm whether the shipment used PSA’s label or your own label before discussing compensation.
• Ask your submitting dealer about the order if the submission went through that dealer.
• Compare the grading fee refund and item compensation separately. Ask PSA how the declared maximum insured value applies to each missing item.

Related: Grading news.